Root Cause Analysis: A Practical Guide to Solving Equipment Failures

Introduction:

Root cause analysis (RCA) is a key component of maintenance aimed at finding and ridding the root causes of equipment breakdowns. RCA is a solution to the root cause rather than a solution to the symptoms of the problems, and ensuring the repeated problems do not happen, hence increasing the stability and efficiency of operations at the organization.

The importance of Root Cause Analysis in Maintenance

Effective RCA can:
● Reduce the downtime and maintenance costs.
● Enhance the  reliability of equipment.
● Improve overall manufacturing efficiency.
So that the aim is to provide sustainable solutions, not quick fixes. This guide leads you step-by-step to implement a strong RCA program.

Step For Successful Root Cause Analysis

1. Setup and Documentation
● Depending on the size of the plant, failure logs can be compared daily, weekly, or monthly to capture possible failures that require investigation.
● Create RCA triggers (e.g., establish a baseline service life for equipment, such as motors that fail in less than three years).
● Always prioritize root cause analysis (RCA) for critical equipment, irrespective of trigger criteria.

2. Creating a Root Cause Analysis Database
● Centralized Failure Database: A centralized database for tracking failures is a must. Include:
● Location, name, and number of equipment
● Dates of failure and history of failures
● Concise explanations of the failure and solutions offered.
● Individuals are responsible and deadlines.

3. Gathering Equipment Information and History
● Gather detailed failure information, such as asset history and repair attempts.
● Conduct interviews with operators, mechanics, and shift personnel for direct accounts.
● If you can, observe the running conditions of the equipment as visual indicators of potential failure, such as leaks or abnormal vibrations.
● It is essential to have documentation of root cause analysis
The Importance of Taking Pictures:
● Document damage for clarity.
● Upload screenshots during report reviews.
● Back findings up with irrefutable evidence.

4. Writing Comprehensive Reports
When drafting RCA reports:
● Use clear, simple language.
● Avoid blame; focus on facts.
● Details like Equipment specifics, failures, recommendations, photos, etc, should be included.

5. Solutions Review and Implementation
● Distribute reports earlier so they are prepared.
● Be sure to have all the key stakeholders in place; area managers, engineers, and maintenance should be required to attend.
● Work on answers to achieve mass commitment.

6. Assigning Changes & Tracking
● Designate persons to carry out solutions with timelines.
● Plan follow-up sessions to check on progress and evaluate the effectiveness of changes made.

Common Symptoms in Machinery

When someone piece of machinery breaks down, it typically does so by presenting you with one or more of the following signs:
1. Oxidized Oil
When the oil is subjected to extreme temperatures or contamination, it can break down and lose its effectiveness, leading to a condition known as oil degradation, which can be harmful to components.
2. Destructive Pitting
Where there is surface pitting of the components, metal fatigue, or less lubrication can affect machinery strength.
3. Excessive Vibration
Any vibration alerts indicate that a misalignment, imbalance, or wear has occurred that could cause component failure if not corrected quickly.
4. Abrasive Wear
The particulate in the lubricant acts like sandpaper, wearing away the surface of machinery components.
5. Cavitation
To this phenomenon, bubbles in vapor form inside the fluid, which often results in pitting and other structural damages.
6. Abnormal Noise
Odd noises have a tendency to point toward a mechanical problem, such as an imbalance or misalignment, or insufficient lubrication.
7. Wear Debris Generation
Wear particles appear in oil when any component wears out, and their gradual accumulation is a strong sign that things have begun to degrade.
8. High Running Temperature
Friction, poor lubrication, or ineffective parts of the cooling system often lead to excessive heat.

The 4-R Approach: A Temporary Fix

The traditional 4-R approach, which can be thought of as Repair, Replace, Rebuild, Remove, addresses the symptoms and not the root cause. This fixes the problem temporarily, but it does not work for long because the root of the problem is not resolved. However, in order to maintain long-term machinery health, we cannot just take superficial steps.

Reasons Behind The Symptoms Of Machinery

The only way to really get rid of machinery issues fast is to nip the root cause in the bud. The most frequent root causes include:
1. Misalignment
Unaligned rotating equipment will cause uneven wear, excessive vibration, and less efficient operation.
2. Wrong Oil Usage
Applying an improper lubricant can lead to slow performance and increased wear. Always adhere to the manufacturer's instructions.
3. Moisture Contamination
In oil, water ingress can cause oxidation, corrosion, and loss of lubrication properties.
4. Machinery Part Imbalance
Unbalance in rotating parts for more vibrations, resulting in premature wear and ultimate stator failure.
5. Particle Contamination
In oil, solid particles work as abrasives, damaging surfaces and shortening machinery life.
6. Air Contamination
The presence of air bubbles in the lubrication system can influence oil efficiency and cause cavitation.

The 5-I Approach for Sustainable Remedy

A proactive maintenance strategy is based on the 5-I:
1. Cleanliness
Due to the abrasive wear from contamination, you should wash the lubricants and the components that influence the lubricants.
2. Cooling
Have good cooling systems for maintaining proper temperatures and preventing oil from oxidizing.
3. Dryness
High-quality seals and routine inspections can prevent moisture ingress that can accelerate corrosion and lubrication failure.
4. Alignment and Balance
Monitor and correct misalignment and imbalance regularly to minimize vibration and wear.
5. Proper Lubrication
Polish your gear- use proper lubricant in the right volume to keep it operating smoothly and efficiently.
For More Information About Lubrication Reliability - Click Here

Best Practices Root Cause Analysis

1. Data Collection: Collect symptoms and  whether it's working.
2. Observation: Check for apparent signs of use or harm on your machines.
3. Testing: Use vibration analyzers and oil condition monitors.
4. Analysis: Identify the cause based on the results
5. Implementation: Use categorized solutions to remove the causes of concern.

Tools and Techniques for Diagnosis

• Vibration analysis: To detect misalignment, imbalance, and wear
• Oil Analysis: Contamination & degradation detection
• Thermal Imaging: Spotlights temperature excesses
• Ultrasonic Testing: It is used for the detection of cavitation and leak detection.
• Laser alignment tools: Make sure everything is lined up perfectly.

Conclusion

Apart from keeping track of overall operational efficiency with minimal downtime, understanding the root causes behind machinery symptoms is also one of the core mandates. The 5-I strategy, in addition to 4-R, helps you to ensure that your machine remains healthy and reliable for a long time. This facilitates ongoing guidance and analysis with early maintenance of sustainable solutions.

Learn more about our services and industry insights by visiting our official LinkedIn page: Minimac Systems

FAQs